Browsing by Author "Chun-yen Chen"

Now showing 1 - 6 of 6

Foreword : The Common Place of Crime
(英語學系, 2012-03-??) Chun-yen Chen
Foreword : The Common Place of Crime
(英語學系, 2012-03-??) Chun-yen Chen
Foreword: Wings of Patience
(英語學系, 2011-09-??) Chun-yen Chen
Foreword: Wings of Patience
(英語學系, 2011-09-??) Chun-yen Chen
對《戀愛中的女人》原始主義之再思
(2011) 王莉菁; Wang, Li-Jing
本論文主張，在「原始主義」的外表下，也就是西方與非西方之二元理論基礎，勞倫斯在《戀愛中的女人》，運用此種比喻以及其他相關的二元對立觀念，於實質上強調了均衡的議題（精神、心理、身體、文化等層面）。第一章廣泛地討論了二十世紀的藝術中，對原始意象的再現；並歸納出對於原始他者的再現方式有二：其一是延續了對原始他者所產生的兩種極端投射，其二則藉由此他者提供了混雜性，為抵抗文化階級帶來更多的可能。我從這些不同的再現意義出發，深入探討《戀愛中的女人》何以被解讀成是一部帶有原始主義意識型態的小說（第二章與第三章），以及為何必須正面看待這小說的「原始主義」（第四章）。第二章聚焦在女性的「文化形象」，呈現女性角色與非洲意象的象徵性連結。第三章分析男性角色的文化形象，以及男性角色與小說中所稱的「北方原則」，也就是陽剛的西方意象，之間的象徵性連結。第四章交叉地解讀這些角色的文化形象，同時試圖闡明角色與意象間複雜的交錯相關性（比如：女性角色與北方原則的共通性，以及男性角色與非洲意象的相似處）。我認為這些隱含在小說中的交錯性面向，一方面顛覆了一般認為原始主義只會傳遞性別層面的意識型態之看法；另一方面也推翻了北方與非洲意象的對立衝突性。最後我希望透過此論文呈現出，《戀愛中的女人》在某種程度上是二分法的結構，但這正是勞倫斯藉以提倡「平衡的」生活觀與世界觀之途徑。
欲求「圭範」vs. 「規範」欲望：宣成政治，流離主體，與「旅館國家/狀態」
(2013) 張恆睿; Heng-jui Chang
Building on Wayne Koestenbaum’s fragmentary reflections on the hotel in Hotel Theory, this thesis deploys the qualified neologism, “hotel state,” to denote an exilic perspective on “home.” Through this perspective, I hope to explore the productive connection between Judith Butler’s theory of performativity and the realism discussed in Anglo-American ethical and political philosophy, with Hegel, Spinoza, and J.L. Austin as common grounds between the two. The connection between Butler and realism refines and problematizes Butler’s formulations of home and exile, desire and recognition, in the issues of Israel/ Palestine and gay marriage. After a chapter-length discussion on each, I take the Jewish-Arab inter-racial homosexuality presented in Israeli director Eytan Fox’s film, The Bubble, and the film’s perceived failure, as a test case to summarily drive home the realism into which I hope to extend Butler’s theory, and with which to supplement the normative dimension that is lacking in it. The realism in question shares with Butler’s performative ethics/politics a rejection of both foundationalism and communitarianism. Home, viewed through foundationalism, is a label attachable to any context, provided that a basis in liberal consensus and individualist respect stands. The goal, on the foundationalist model, then, is to construct such a basis, regardless of cultural or historical differences. Contrarily, communitarianism, in emphasizing solidarity and cultural autonomy, rejects the foundationalists’ thin notion of home. In its salutary stress on the local and the specific, nevertheless, it risks either subjecting home to localist determinism or rendering it an apology for relativism (with recourse to the atomistic individual). Taking the realist and Butlerian middle way in rejecting both, the “hotel state” proposed in this thesis portrays home, or subjectivity, as displaced, linked to an unwilled, unpredictable and local network of relationality that both constitutes a challenge to the bounded subject assumed by foundationalism and a plurality that captures the performative creativity and transferentiality, pivoted on transience, of local affinities. The “hotel state” finds its inspiration in the “hotel,” meant to evoke associations with placeness, instituionality, and various social statuses such as can be conjured up at the mentioning of “hotel.” Hotel needs management, in the way that an anti-foundationalist realism, assessing political and ethical issues from inside a parochial perspective, has to answer normative problems. The specifying, normative associations of hotel, together with the capacity of a hotel point of view to pivot “inhabitation of space” upon voyage, cohabitation with strangers, and the freedom and unfreedom of exile, form the focal point of this thesis. The thesis embarks on two trajectories. One consists of a recontextualization of Judith Butler’s theory of “performativity” and “social ontology” in light of “realism,” premised upon the “hotel state.” The other, closely related, ventures a historical, conceptual analysis of the intertwining issues of Israel/Palestine and gay marriage. The latter’s challenges to the former I would try to meet with a fine-tuning of Butlerian realism, elucidating the relation between “hotel state” and the ethics of cohabitation. The first chapter launches the project by reshaping the terrain of Butler study. It revisits “performativity” and “social ontology” by tracing their genealogy in Butler back to Spinoza and Hegel, so as to bring them, via this metaphysical origin, to realism. The resistance of Butler’s theory to metaphysics is weakened not only by its genealogical link with metaphysics but by its anti-positivist intentionality. By emphasizing this strand in Butler’s thought, I distinguish her theory from the strong anti-metaphysical constructivism alongside which her writing is often read. Realism, invoked here through Hegel, Iris Murdoch and Bernard Williams, hinges on reality both as immanent to a local outlook, pivoted on local praxis, and as transcendent to the representation conferred by the epistemic norm which structures the local context. I argue that the perception of reality, which pits the norms against their own limits, would require the subject to attend to reality in both the immanent register and the transcendent register. Ethical realism, as propounded by Murdoch and Williams, entails that transformation and progress must be derived from local critique, one that is informed by history and apprehends the reality that transcends the epistemic norm governing the local context. The power struggle routed through bodies and institutions in the probelmatization of the norms’ legitimacy, on the other hand, signifies political realism. Considering ethical and political realism together, I name Williams and Judith Shklar as thinkers who recognize the necessity for political realism to go hand in hand with ethical realism. The degree to which the particular reality and the particular individual mirror each other in ethical and political realism bridges the gap between the individualistic politics and other-oriented ethics in Butler’s theory of performativity, at the same time that it critiques liberal individualism with an emphasis on reality. To further my theorization of the hotel state apropos Butler and realism, I study the intersections of identity in the Jewish/Palestinian question, compounded by homosexuality, as well as the desire for norm, against normative desire, in the debate over gay marriage in the US. The two converge when we consider the vulnerability of life, and, as Butler enjoins over and over, the varying recognition of such vulnerability in different groups. I raise Fox’s badly received popular film, The Bubble, as a case where the internally vexed clusters of identity and normative issues further crisscross into each other. The aim, as I sum up in the coda, is to see what different “future” realism, in the grip of pessimism and “left melancholia,” may lead. The task I set myself in these chapters is, first, to engage both historically and theoretically the coercive and productive aspects of norms manifested at the crossroads between groups, as well as between group membership and allegiance to group, and second, to theorize on a form of affiliation and hospitality, apropos Butlerian realism, that attends not only to the phenomenological aspects of the crossroads, but also to their normative resolutions. All in all, I argue that the “hotel state” is a phenomenological precondition of ethical perception that displaces “home” from its possessive, individualist, exclusionary grid, enabling a model of spatial practice and accommodation attuned to the reality both partially represented as the “ethical fact” of a particular form of life, and as beyond that representation, keeping alive an unknown prospect that can challenge that form of life should life in it be rendered unlivable. As such, “hotel state” comprises a fruitful link between realism and hospitality, between the realism in Anglo-American philosophy and the realism in Butler’s poststructuralist Hegelianism, constituting an inviting point of departure for the renewal of both.